top of page

Paul Chaleff at MoMA | Two Letters and a Film in Progress

1 minute ago
3 min read

When I met Tanja Hwang at the Museum of Modern Art on September 24, she brought a manila folder to the table. I had my camera running as she set it down and opened it. Inside was correspondence between Paul Chaleff and the museum, including a handwritten letter Paul sent in 1984 and a typed letter MoMA sent him two years later. Tanja and I also talked that day about her visiting Paul at his studio in Ancram, New York. She has since made that visit.


Tanja Hwang brings Paul Chaleff’s correspondence to the table at MoMA.

On May 8, 1984, Paul wrote to Arthur Drexler in MoMA’s Department of Architecture and Design. He was proud to see his work in the galleries and particularly pleased with the pieces Drexler had chosen. Then he went on to tell Drexler what he’d noticed about the other ceramics on display. He loved the Rosanjin jar and thought the two George Ohr pieces had “tremendous vitality.” They reminded him of a Chinese cup with a similarly pinched handle. Paul had tried making a cup on the wheel with a handle formed from the same clay, without attaching it separately. He knew how difficult it was to do well, and that was part of what he admired in Ohr.


Paul Chaleff to Arthur Drexler, May 8, 1984.
Paul Chaleff to Arthur Drexler, May 8, 1984.

The letter from MoMA is much shorter. In November 1986, curator Stuart Wrede wrote to tell Paul that the Architecture and Design Committee had voted to bring one of his covered jars into the design collection. A few typed lines record a decision whose consequences are still with us. The museum took responsibility for preserving the jar, and future curators could decide where it belonged in an exhibition and what other works might help us see it. In his letter to Drexler, Paul was doing some of that looking himself. He brought to the gallery a potter’s knowledge of how a handle takes shape and a memory of another cup he had seen years before.


Stuart Wrede to Paul Chaleff, November 1986.
Stuart Wrede to Paul Chaleff, November 1986.

That exchange is one of the things I’m interested in as I make Paul Chaleff: Thinking in Clay. When William and I filmed Paul in Ancram, we could stay with him as a piece took shape and see the decisions that a finished object leaves us to work out for ourselves. At the museum, the same object can be seen in the company of things Paul may never have considered alongside it. I’m curious about what each setting lets us see, and what happens when the artist gets to tell the museum what he sees there, as Paul did in his letter to Drexler.

That question comes up again in January. Tanja’s exhibition, Bold Is Better: ’80s and ’90s Design, runs January 17 through May 22, 2027, in MoMA’s Philip Johnson Galleries. Organized with Amanda Forment and Paul Galloway, it brings together nearly 150 works, drawn primarily from the museum’s collection. Shiro Kuramata’s expanded-metal armchair, Martin Margiela’s Tabi boots and Apple’s iMac are among the objects through which the exhibition looks at storytelling, popular culture and experiments with materials. Paul’s ceramics are expected to be part of that broader account of design. MoMA exhibition announcement⁠

What I find promising in Tanja’s approach is that it gives visitors a reason to look at ceramics even if they came to see something else. A visitor drawn to Kuramata’s chair might already be thinking about what happens when a familiar object is made in an unexpected way. A few steps farther into the exhibition, that same curiosity can carry over to a vessel. Paul’s 1984 letter shows what can come of that kind of looking. He went to see how MoMA had displayed his work and came away thinking about how George Ohr had made a handle.

I’m grateful to Sheila Parekh and Carrie Chen for supporting the film and giving us time to follow this story from the studio to the museum. I’m happy for Paul, too. More than forty years after he wrote to Drexler, a new audience will have the chance to spend time with his work. I’d love to walk through the exhibition with him and see what catches his eye this time.

If you’d like to follow Paul Chaleff: Thinking in Clay as we make it, subscribe to the journal. I’ll share dispatches from the studio, discoveries from the research, and short clips from the filming as the work unfolds. It’s a way to come along with us and see the film take shape.

Comments


 © 2025-26 | Heritage Film Project, LLC | Documentary Film Fund

bottom of page